Stop Rewarding Firefighting: The Hidden Cost of Hero Culture in Supply Chains

Sheri Hinish, Founder of Supply Chain Queen® and CEO of Supply Chain Revolution Global, goes solo for the first time on the Supply Chain Revolution® podcast to ask a question that makes many leaders shift in their seats: are we rewarding the people who keep the crisis going? In this episode, she explains why firefighting quietly becomes the operating model in so many supply chains, what that hero culture costs in money, carbon, people, and strategy, and four practical ways leaders can start rewarding the people who keep crises from happening.

SH
Sheri Hinish November 2026 • Supply Chain Revolution Podcast, Solo Episode
Supply Chain Leadership Resilience Culture

Are We Rewarding the People Who Keep the Crisis Going?

I have spent my career inside supply chains, first as a practitioner, then in technology, and later as a Senior Partner at IBM and EY, advising some of the largest companies in the world. In every one of those chapters, I watched the same movie play out.

A shipment is about to miss. Someone books an expedite, calls in a favor, or stays online until midnight, and the order goes out. On Monday, leadership sends an email that says, “Outstanding teamwork,” and everyone feels great. Three weeks later, the same movie plays again with the same plot, the same cast, and the same ending.

Why Does Firefighting Become the Operating Model?

My perspective is simple. In many organizations, firefighting has quietly become the operating model. Nobody chose it in a strategy session. It grew one heroic save at a time, because the rescue is visible and prevention is not.

“Firefighting grew one heroic save at a time, because the rescue is visible and prevention is not.”

Sheri Hinish, Supply Chain Queen®

Researchers at MIT named this pattern more than two decades ago. In their 2001 California Management Review article, “Nobody Ever Gets Credit for Fixing Problems that Never Happened,” Nelson Repenning and John Sterman showed how pressure to deliver today pulls people away from improvement work. Capability erodes, the problems multiply, and the organization grows ever more dependent on firefighting. They called this dynamic the capability trap, and I still see it in boardrooms and on warehouse floors.

What Does Firefighting Really Cost a Supply Chain?

The thank-you email never comes with an invoice. The real bill arrives in three places: your cost and carbon numbers, your people, and your strategy.

The financial and carbon cost

Every expedite carries a premium. Every shipment that flies when it should have sailed adds cost and carbon at the same time. As someone who has led sustainability practices at global scale, I will say this plainly: some of the most avoidable emissions in a supply chain are hiding inside its firefighting. A late decision becomes an air freight booking, and that booking becomes a number in next year’s sustainability report that someone has to explain.

20x+
more CO2 per ton-mile when freight shifts from ocean to air

FreightWaves has reported that switching freight from ocean to air can increase emissions by more than 20 times per ton-mile. That mode shift is rarely a deliberate sustainability choice. It is usually the downstream consequence of a decision that came too late.

The people cost

Heroes burn out. Over time, the people who prevent problems stop raising their hands, because they have learned that the organization only notices noise. The culture begins to confuse being busy with being valuable. If that sounds familiar, you are in good company.

The strategic cost

The strategic cost may be the largest of all. When your best people spend their weeks on rescue missions, nobody has time for the work that builds resilience: scenario planning, supplier development, cleaning the data, and piloting the AI innovation that might have seen the problem coming. You cannot transform a supply chain with a team that is permanently on call.

Where Do Recurring Supply Chain Crises Come From?

Before we blame individuals, we need to look at the system, because most recurring crises are designed into it. Here is the pattern I have seen across industries. Procurement is measured on unit price. The warehouse is measured on space and capacity. Customer service is measured on fill rate. Each team hits its number, and the customer still loses, because nobody owns the handoffs in between.

Someone has to reconcile all of those conflicting decisions at the last minute, and we call that person a hero. The praise is sincere, but it also lets the underlying trade-off survive for another month or another quarter.

“Where does success in one part of our business create an emergency for someone else?”

The question to put on the table at your next leadership meeting

If the room goes quiet, you have probably found your next transformation priority.

Related reading: Why Your Talent Strategy Is Your Supply Chain Transformation Strategy

How Can Leaders Reward the People Who Prevent Crises?

I have four suggestions for leaders who want to start rewarding the people who keep the crisis from happening.

1. Measure the fingerprints of firefighting

Track expedite spend, premium freight, schedule changes inside the frozen window, and overtime driven by late decisions. These numbers belong on the same dashboard as your service levels, because they tell you what your service level actually costs.

2. Tell prevention stories with the same energy as rescue stories

When a planner catches forecast drift early and sets up an earlier review with sales, show what changed: fewer last-minute revisions, fewer expedites, and calmer seas. Be honest about what you can prove, because credibility will always outlast a dramatic savings number.

3. Change the question in your team meetings

Instead of asking who saved the day this month, ask what became easier this month because someone improved how we work. The question you repeat every week tells your team what you value.

4. Use technology to see the smoke before the fire

The real promise of AI in planning is earlier signals and more time to make a good decision. However, the best early warning system in the world will not help you if your culture still rewards only the rescue.

What Should Leaders Ask After a Supply Chain Crisis?

After a crisis, everyone is exhausted and wants to move on, which is exactly when the learning disappears. Keep the review short enough that it actually happens, and ask three questions.

1. When did we have the first useful signal?

2. What made it hard to act on that signal?

3. What specific change will we make, who owns it, and when will we check whether it worked?

In my experience, the second question is where the gold is. People often had the information, but they lacked the authority, the time, or the air cover to act on it.

Be ready to hear that you helped start the fire

Here is the hardest part for leaders. Be ready to hear that one of your own decisions helped start the fire. Perhaps you delayed a trade-off. Perhaps everything stayed a priority, or perhaps you praised people for absorbing work that should have been resourced. How you respond in that moment determines how honest the next review will be, so be vulnerable, be transparent, and be accountable for the fires you caused.

Related reading: When Performance Is Exceptional, Does Integrity Still Matter?

What If You Are the Hero?

If you are reading this and thinking that the hero is you, I see you, and this part is for you. Your ability to rescue the business is a real skill. Your next level of leadership, however, depends on building the capability that makes those rescues unnecessary.

Start by making the pattern visible. You might say, “This is the third time this quarter we have needed an emergency workaround for this issue. Here is what each response costs us. Can we set aside time to fix the cause?”

Document what only you know. Train a backup, and put your preventive work in your updates. If you take a vacation and everything runs smoothly, treat that as proof of your leadership rather than a threat to your relevance. Leave ego and title at the door. Your job is to give your job away, so that someone else can step into your role and you can move on to the next layer of your leadership journey.

“Heroics are a lagging indicator. Resilience is the leading one, and it is built in the quiet weeks and moments that nobody celebrates.”

Sheri Hinish, Supply Chain Queen®

Key Takeaways for Supply Chain and Operations Leaders

Firefighting is a system outcome. Siloed metrics in procurement, warehousing, and customer service design recurring crises into the operating model, and heroics keep the underlying trade-offs alive.

Firefighting has a measurable bill. Expedite premiums, premium freight, avoidable air freight emissions, burnout, and lost strategic capacity all belong in the conversation about service levels.

Make prevention visible. Put the fingerprints of firefighting on the service dashboard, and tell prevention stories with the same energy as rescue stories.

Learn after every fire. A short review that asks about the first useful signal, the barriers to acting on it, and the specific change and owner turns a crisis into capability.

Leaders go first. Honest reviews depend on leaders who can hear that their own decisions helped start the fire.

Frequently Asked Questions About Firefighting Culture

What is firefighting culture in supply chain management?

Firefighting culture describes an organization that routinely solves recurring problems through last-minute heroics, such as expedites, favors, and overtime, and then celebrates those rescues while the root causes remain in place. Over time, the rescue becomes the operating model.

What is the capability trap?

The capability trap is a dynamic described by MIT researchers Nelson Repenning and John Sterman. Pressure to hit short-term targets pulls people away from improvement work, capability erodes, problems multiply, and the organization becomes more dependent on firefighting.

How do you measure the cost of firefighting in a supply chain?

Track expedite spend, premium freight, schedule changes inside the frozen window, and overtime driven by late decisions, and report those figures on the same dashboard as service levels so leaders can see what each service level actually costs.

How does firefighting increase supply chain emissions?

Late decisions often turn into air freight, which emits far more carbon per ton-mile than ocean freight. FreightWaves has reported that shifting freight from ocean to air can increase emissions by more than 20 times per ton-mile, so earlier decisions can remove some of the most avoidable emissions in a supply chain.

How can leaders reward prevention instead of firefighting?

Leaders can measure the fingerprints of firefighting, tell prevention stories with the same energy as rescue stories, ask what became easier because someone improved how the team works, and pair AI-enabled early warning with a culture that rewards early action.

Who Gets the Credit in Your Organization?

The next time everything runs smoothly, get curious. Ask whose preparation made that possible. Ask who raised the difficult question early, who cleaned the data, who trained the backup, and who made the trade-off before the deadline became impossible. Those are the people building your resilience, and they deserve the spotlight.

I want to hear your stories. In your organization, who gets more recognition: the person who prevents the problem or the person who fixes it? Send me a message on LinkedIn or tag me in a post.

Sheri Hinish is the Founder of Supply Chain Queen® and CEO of Supply Chain Revolution Global. She hosts the Supply Chain Revolution® podcast. Previously she served as EY’s Global Consulting Leader for Sustainability, Technology, and Ecosystems and as a Senior Executive at IBM, advising Fortune 500 companies and governments on supply chain transformation, AI-enabled operations, sustainability, and innovation. She holds advanced degrees from Harvard University and Rutgers University and is recognized as the #1 Global Supply Chain Influencer. Supply chain resilience, leadership, and the culture that sustains transformation are central themes of her advisory and media work.

Learn More

Research: Repenning and Sterman, California Management Review (2001)  |  Podcast: The Supply Chain Revolution®  |  Supply Chain Queen: supplychainqueen.com

If this episode brought a colleague to mind, share it with them, because it might start the most useful conversation your team has had all month. Follow Supply Chain Revolution on YouTube, Apple Podcasts, and Spotify so you never miss an episode. Until next time, keep leading the revolution.

About the Author

Sheri Hinish is the Founder of Supply Chain Queen® and CEO of Supply Chain Revolution Global LLC, a supply chain thought leadership, advisory, media, and community platform. Previously she served as EY’s Global Consulting Leader for Sustainability, Technology, and Ecosystems and as a Senior Executive at IBM, advising Fortune 500 companies and governments on supply chain transformation, AI-enabled operations, sustainability, circular economy, and climate strategy. She holds advanced degrees from Harvard University and Rutgers University and is recognized as the #1 Global Supply Chain Influencer, a Top 250 Global Leader in Sustainability, Top 100 Women in Supply Chain and Technology, and Top 100 B2B Influencer in North America. She hosts the Supply Chain Revolution® podcast and speaks globally at COP, NY Climate Week, CES, and major industry events.

Sheri Hinish is the Supply Chain Queen®, Founder and CEO of Supply Chain Revolution Global, and a former Senior Partner at EY and IBM. Learn more about Sheri, her credentials and her advisory work.

Explore More Blog Posts

Stop Rewarding Firefighting: The Hidden Cost of Hero Culture in Supply Chains

Sheri Hinish, Founder of Supply Chain Queen® and CEO of Supply Chain Revolution Global, goes…

What If Jensen Huang Were a Woman? The CEO Grace Gap

A week after Jensen Huang resigned as Nvidia's CEO, a campaign to bring him back…

Meet the SCQ Fellows 2027: The Next Generation of Supply Chain Leadership

Sheri Hinish introduces the SCQ Fellows 2027, five emerging leaders who will work across media,…

Why Your Talent Strategy Is Your Supply Chain Transformation Strategy

Supply chain transformations succeed or stall on people, because AI changes who makes which decisions.…

Agentic AI in the Back Office: How Flex Automates 95% of Work Order Approvals

Sheri Hinish, Founder of Supply Chain Queen® and CEO of Supply Chain Revolution Global, hosts…

When Performance Is Exceptional, Does Integrity Still Matter?

Sheri Hinish, Founder of Supply Chain Queen® and CEO of Supply Chain Revolution Global, argues…